The best pizza in Athens GA includes quick slices, neighborhood favorites, patios, and more polished artisan pies. The right choice depends on whether you want convenience, a sit-down meal, a group-friendly stop, or something close to the rest of your plans.
Automatic Pizza
For New York-style slices or a whole pie, Automatic Pizza is a pizza-first stop in Normaltown. Its retro former gas-station setting makes it a distinctive choice while exploring Prince Avenue. The Normaltown location and slice-friendly format make it an easy neighborhood meal rather than a long dining commitment.
Best for: New York-style slices and an easy Normaltown stop.
Planning tip: Pair it with another Prince Avenue or Normaltown stop so the trip across town does more than cover one meal.
Ted’s Most Best
Ted’s Most Best pairs artisan pizza with a large patio and bocce court. Its downtown location makes it especially practical for a relaxed group meal before a North Campus walk or nearby event. The patio and downtown-adjacent setting make it especially useful for groups, families, and casual meals before other central Athens plans.
Best for: Artisan pizza, a patio, and a casual meal near downtown.
Planning tip: Use it before a downtown event or North Campus walk so parking and transportation stay simple.
Peppino’s Pizzeria
Peppino’s is a straightforward, old-school neighborhood pizzeria on Whitehall Road—best for a casual pizza-focused meal outside the busiest downtown blocks. Its old-school neighborhood feel provides a different pizza experience from the busier downtown options.
Best for: A casual, pizza-first meal away from the busiest central blocks.
Planning tip: Check current hours before making the drive, especially if the rest of your itinerary is centered downtown.
DePalma’s Italian Cafe
DePalma’s is a longstanding Athens Italian restaurant with multiple locations. It’s the flexible choice for groups who want pizza alongside pasta, salads, and other Italian dishes. The broader Italian menu makes it useful when not everyone in the group wants pizza.
Best for: Groups that want pizza plus pasta, salads, and other Italian options.
Planning tip: Choose the location that best fits the rest of your day instead of crossing town solely for the meal.
